
Bile and Methane SIBO: Can Bile Keep Methane in Check?
Key takeaways Methane SIBO is now called intestinal methanogen overgrowth (IMO). It happens when microbes called methanogens make too much ...
0 item(s)
Free delivery on tests
Bile acid malabsorption (BAM) is when bile acids are not properly recycled by the small intestine. Instead, they spill into the colon. There, they pull in water and speed up the gut, causing chronic watery diarrhoea. It is also called bile acid diarrhoea (BAD) or bile salt malabsorption [1].
Bile acids are made in your liver from cholesterol. They are stored in your gallbladder and released after you eat to help you digest fat.
Normally, your body recycles almost all of them. Less than 5% escape being reabsorbed at the end of the small intestine, called the terminal ileum [2]. The rest travel back to the liver to be used again.
In BAM, too many bile acids reach the colon. This can happen because the ileum can’t reabsorb them, or because the liver makes too many [1]. Researchers increasingly use the name “bile acid diarrhoea” because true malabsorption is not always the cause.
More than 1 in 4 people diagnosed with IBS-D have bile acid malabsorption. A 2015 meta-analysis of 908 patients found a pooled rate of 28% [3]. Across the general population, it is thought to affect about 1% of people [5].
An earlier review of 1,223 patients with IBS-D found these rates by severity [4]:
| Severity (SeHCAT result) | Share of IBS-D patients |
|---|---|
| Severe (under 5%) | 10% |
| Moderate (under 10%) | 32% |
| Mild (under 15%) | 26% |
The studies in each row differ, so these figures don’t add up to one total. Even so, BAM is often missed, partly because many doctors don’t think to test for it [1].
The main symptom is chronic, watery diarrhoea that is often urgent. Many people also have tummy discomfort and bloating [6]. People with severe BAM may also have pale, greasy stools (steatorrhoea) [7].
Common symptoms include:
The timing of symptoms can be a clue. If you’ve had surgery to remove part of the ileum (the last section of the small intestine), you may notice diarrhoea comes on mainly after meals. This is a typical pattern when BAM is caused by this kind of surgery [8].
BAM and IBS-D can feel almost the same. In one study, doctors could not tell them apart from symptoms alone. Only the SeHCAT test separated them [9].
| Bile acid malabsorption | IBS-D | |
|---|---|---|
| What causes it | Too many bile acids reaching the colon | No single cause; gut–brain, sensitivity and motility changes |
| Main symptom | Watery, urgent diarrhoea | Tummy pain linked to bowel movements, with loose stools |
| Fatty food | Often a clear trigger | May or may not be a trigger |
| How it’s confirmed | SeHCAT scan or C4 blood test | Symptom criteria, after other causes are ruled out |
| Response to bile acid binders | Often good | Usually little effect, unless BAM is present |
If you have an IBS-D diagnosis and treatment hasn’t helped, ask your GP whether BAM has been considered.
There are three types of BAM. Type 1 is caused by damage to, or removal of, the terminal ileum. Type 2 has no obvious cause. Type 3 happens alongside other conditions, such as gallbladder removal, coeliac disease or SIBO [1] [6].
| Type | What’s going on | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Type 1 | The terminal ileum is damaged or missing, so it can’t reabsorb bile acids | Crohn’s disease of the ileum, surgery to remove the ileum, radiotherapy damage |
| Type 2 (primary or idiopathic) | No damage. The liver makes too many bile acids | Often diagnosed as IBS-D |
| Type 3 | Another condition disturbs how bile acids are handled | Gallbladder removal, SIBO, coeliac disease, chronic pancreatitis |
Type 2 is the most common type in people labelled with IBS-D. It seems to be a signalling problem, not an absorption problem [10].
When bile acids are reabsorbed, the ileum releases a hormone called FGF19. FGF19 tells the liver to slow down bile acid production. People with Type 2 BAM have low FGF19, so the liver keeps making bile acids. This overwhelms the gut’s ability to recycle them [10] [11].
Low FGF19 has also been found in people with diarrhoea after gallbladder removal [10].
Yes. Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO) is a recognised cause of Type 3 BAM [1]. If you have both, treating only one may not fully settle your symptoms.
In SIBO, bacteria in the small intestine break down (deconjugate) bile acids too early. This lowers the amount of working bile acids available to digest fat, which can lead to fat malabsorption [12].
The link may also run the other way. Bile acids help keep bacteria in check, and lower bile acid levels in the gut are linked with bacterial overgrowth [13]. Whether this makes SIBO more likely in people with BAM has not been directly tested.
If your symptoms include bloating, wind or diarrhoea, a breath test can check for SIBO. Healthpath’s SIBO Test tests for both hydrogen and methane-producing overgrowth. Please note it does not test for BAM.
In the UK, BAM is diagnosed with a SeHCAT scan or a C4 blood test, depending on what your local hospital offers. British Society of Gastroenterology (BSG) guidelines recommend making a positive diagnosis with one of these tests, rather than just trying treatment [8]. A stool test cannot diagnose BAM.
Before testing for BAM, your GP will usually rule out other causes. BSG guidelines recommend blood tests (for example, for anaemia and coeliac disease) and a stool test for gut inflammation [8]. If BAM is suspected, you will usually be referred to a gastroenterologist.
The SeHCAT scan is the main UK test. You swallow a capsule containing a man-made bile acid with a tiny amount of a radioactive marker. A scanner measures how much is in your body soon after, then again 7 days later. NICE has published guidance on its use [14].
| SeHCAT 7-day retention | What it means | Response to colestyramine |
|---|---|---|
| Over 15% | Normal | — |
| 10–15% | Mild BAM | 70% |
| 5–10% | Moderate BAM | 80% |
| Under 5% | Severe BAM | 96% |
Thresholds from [15]; response rates pooled from 15 studies [4].
SeHCAT is often only available in specialist centres [15], and it is not available in many countries [1].
C4 (7α-hydroxy-4-cholesten-3-one) is a substance made when the liver produces bile acids. A high fasting level suggests the liver is making too many. It is the main alternative to SeHCAT in the BSG guidelines [8].
Fasting FGF19 is mainly used in research. In one study of 101 people with IBS-D, C4 and FGF19 had specificities of 83% and 78%. C4 was the more reliable of the two [5].
Some doctors try a bile acid binder and see if symptoms improve. BSG guidelines say there isn’t enough evidence to recommend this instead of a proper test though [8].
A stool microbiome test cannot diagnose BAM. But BAM is linked to changes in gut bacteria. One study found lower bacterial diversity in people with BAM than in people with IBS-D. It’s not yet clear whether this is a cause or a result of BAM [2].
Healthpath’s Ultimate Gut Test looks at the make-up and diversity of your gut bacteria. It can add context alongside medical testing, not replace it. If SIBO hasn’t been tested for, then SIBO testing would be a more worthwhile investigation considering it’s potential to cause BAM.
The main treatment is a bile acid binder (sequestrant), prescribed by your doctor. These medicines bind bile acids in the gut so they can’t irritate the colon. A lower-fat diet and treating any underlying cause, such as SIBO, can also help.
| Medicine | UK brand | Form | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Colestyramine | Questran | Powder mixed with water | Usually tried first, but many people find the taste and texture hard [15] |
| Colesevelam | Cholestagel | Tablets | Often easier to take. Use for BAM is off-label [16] |
| Colestipol | Colestid | Granules | Used less often in the UK |
These medicines work well for many people. In one review, 70–96% of people responded to colestyramine, with the best results in severe BAM [4]. A 2023 placebo-controlled trial found colesevelam was better than placebo at bringing BAM into remission [17].
Things to know before you start:
For Type 3 BAM, treating the linked condition can improve the diarrhoea [18]. This might mean managing Crohn’s disease, coeliac disease or SIBO.
Researchers are studying medicines that act on the FXR receptor, which helps control bile acid production. These are not yet standard treatment [6].
Yes. Eating less fat can ease symptoms in all types of BAM, and in mild cases it may be enough on its own [18]. Fat is the main trigger for bile release, so less fat means fewer bile acids reaching the colon.
In one UK study, people with BAM followed a dietitian-led diet with about 20% of energy from fat. Their gut symptoms improved in a clinically important way [19].
One NHS hospital leaflet suggests aiming for less than 40g of fat a day [18]:
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| Frying | Grilling, steaming, boiling or dry roasting |
| Fatty meat with skin | Lean meat with skin and fat removed |
| Full-fat milk, cheese and yoghurt | Semi-skimmed or lower-fat versions |
| Generous butter, spreads and oils | About 3 teaspoons (15ml) a day in total |
Ask your GP for a referral to a dietitian. They can help you lower fat without missing out on nutrients.
Soluble fibre, such as oats and psyllium, is gentle on the gut and may help firm up stools. Some types may also bind bile acids, though good trials in BAM are lacking. Rougher, insoluble fibre (bran, skins, seeds) may worsen diarrhoea during flares.
Many people with BAM have first been advised to try a low-FODMAP diet for IBS. This may ease some symptoms but doesn’t address bile acids. It is also meant to be short-term. Cutting fermentable fibre for a long time can reduce the variety of foods that feed your gut bacteria. If you try it, do so with a practitioner and reintroduce foods afterwards.
There is no good evidence yet that probiotics or supplements treat BAM. They don’t replace a proper diagnosis or a bile acid binder.
BAM is linked to changes in gut bacteria, including lower diversity. Some of the bacteria that change bile acids are less common in people with BAM [2]. This makes the microbiome an interesting area for research. But no trials have yet shown that a specific probiotic improves BAM.
Some supplements marketed for “bile support”, such as bitters, aim to increase bile flow. In BAM the problem is too much bile acid reaching the colon, so these are not a logical choice. Some forms of magnesium can also loosen stools. Check with your doctor or a registered practitioner before trying any supplement.
In practice, supporting a varied gut microbiome through a mix of plant foods is a sensible long-term goal, once symptoms are under control. A practitioner can help you reintroduce fibre gradually.
It depends on the type. Type 3 BAM may improve if the linked condition is treated [18]. Types 1 and 2 are usually long-term, but symptoms can often be well managed with medicine and diet.
Living well with BAM often comes down to a few habits:
The UK charity Bile Acid Diarrhoea UK offers patient support and information.
See your GP if you have diarrhoea or looser stools that last 3 weeks or more. Long-term diarrhoea has many possible causes, and some need to be ruled out first [20].
See a GP if you have any of these for 3 weeks or more [20]:
Ask for an urgent GP appointment or call NHS 111 if your poo is black or dark red, or you have bloody diarrhoea [20].
Don’t stop or change any prescribed medicine without talking to your doctor.
Bile acid malabsorption (BAM) is when bile acids aren’t recycled properly by the small intestine. They pass into the colon, where they cause watery diarrhoea and urgency. It is also called bile acid diarrhoea or bile salt malabsorption.
The main symptom is chronic, watery, urgent diarrhoea, often after meals. Others include bloating, tummy cramps and, in severe cases, pale or greasy stools.
More than 1 in 4 people diagnosed with IBS-D have BAM. A 2015 meta-analysis found a pooled rate of 28%.
It is diagnosed with a SeHCAT scan or a C4 blood test, usually through a gastroenterologist. Your GP will first rule out other causes with blood and stool tests.
Retention above 15% at 7 days is normal. 10–15% suggests mild BAM, 5–10% moderate and under 5% severe.
Yes. Gallbladder removal is a recognised cause of Type 3 BAM.
Doctors usually prescribe a bile acid binder, such as colestyramine or colesevelam. A lower-fat diet and treating any underlying cause can also help.
High-fat foods are the main trigger, such as fried food, fatty meat and full-fat dairy. A dietitian can help you lower fat without missing out on nutrients.
No. A gut microbiome test can’t diagnose BAM. It can show the make-up of your gut bacteria, which can add context alongside medical tests.
Yes. SIBO is a recognised cause of Type 3 BAM. Bacteria in the small intestine can break down bile acids too early.
See a GP if your bowel habits have changed for 3 weeks or more. Get urgent help if you have black or dark red poo, or bloody diarrhoea.
This article is for general information only. It is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Always speak to your GP or a qualified healthcare professional about your symptoms or before making changes to your medicines or diet.